• People Talk and My Ear Bleeds

Thoughts

    from Twitter

    News

    Wednesday, December 14, 2005

    Could Vietnam Have Chinese Riots?

    The situation in China stems from economic unrest. China Labor Watch reports that
    The fact that China only stresses economic development has led to a host of social problems. In the course of this development, ordinary people who do not have a say in that development to begin with are paying the price.

    We see that there are increasing numbers of strikes and displays of rebellion by workers. Social instability is becoming increasingly visible. In 2003, there were more than 58,000 industrial conflicts. In 2004, that number reached 74,000.

    The gap between rich and poor is increasing; state-owned factories are closing and going bankrupt; workers are being laid off and losing jobs; peasants are leaving the countryside and entering factories where they have no long-term guarantees.
    The problem with globalization is that
    While free trade has proved highly efficient in generating wealth, it has failed to share the spoils, intensifying gaps between rich and poor, urban and rural. In many instances, new wealth is coming at the direct expense of the poor as local governments sell off land for development projects.

    ...A recent study conducted by the World Bank found that incomes among rural Chinese -- about three-fourths of the total population -- have declined slightly in the years since China entered the WTO, while urban residents have enjoyed modest gains.
    So the message from China is mixed. Yes, over the last 20 years, overall extreme poverty has dropped drastically (from 53% to 8% ... albeit the poverty line is set at between 150-300 yuan), but class separation has increased.

    The CIA reports that
    From 100 to 150 million surplus rural workers are adrift between the villages and the cities, many subsisting through part-time, low-paying jobs. Popular resistance, changes in central policy, and loss of authority by rural cadres have weakened China's population control program, which is essential to maintaining long-term growth in living standards.
    however, unemployment is
    9.8% in urban areas; substantial unemployment and underemployment in rural areas; an official Chinese journal estimated overall unemployment (including rural areas) for 2003 at 20% (2004 est.) [and % of population below poverty line is] 10% (2001 est.)
    Consequently, the rapidly separating classes in China, in addition to the relative ignoring of rural Chinese by the government, set the stage for riots and regime change.

    Also, during the cultural revolution, Mao succeeded in killing many people who believed in democracy who didn't make it to Taiwan. Therefore, the number of people in mainland China who remember democracy and want it is small. This means that although China is dealing with foment and insurrection, change will not happen overnight, but may take 20 years.

    Vietnam poses and interesting comparison to China. It also is a communist-governed country trying to exist with a progressively more open, free-market economy. Consequently, it must grapple with the same issues inherent in a free-market economy that China is currently grappling. However, the demographics of Vietnam and it's political situation are quite different. The United Nations Development Programme shows that Vietnam has 74% of its population in rural areas. China has the same % in rural areas, but is undergoing urbanization much faster, and therefore has a higher % of people in the transient category--without stable jobs or homes in either rural or urban areas. Vietnam has only a 1.9% unemployment rate.

    **This is important. If you list countries by unemployment rate, Vietnam ranks 12th out of 196 countries for whom the CIA publishes data. By comparison, the United States of America ranks 48th with a 5.5% rate and China ranks 89th with a 9.8% rate. **

    According to the national poverty line, Vietnam has a little more poor than China, at 12.9%, but according to the international line it is 28.9%. This is higher than China's published rate, but as I reported earlier, poverty is at thought to be at least 20% in underreported rural areas, and so the figures are probably similar.

    Although poverty is still a problem in Vietnam, one must not underestimate the value of a job--even one that does not put a lot of food on the table. A job helps a person to feel he/she has self worth, gives him/her less time to be discontent and as shown in Vietnam, can allow a family to join together funds to help one member gain education and move up the social ladder. That being said, Vietnam has dealt with riots. This was talked about in The Economist, (subscription required) almost five years ago, when The Economist wrote,
    political pressures and criticism will keep bubbling up. Along the main avenue in Ho Chi Minh City, a group of some 100 protesting peasants have been allowed, for months, to voice their anger publicly at being displaced from their land. ...The banners and placards are critical of official decisions—although they avoid direct criticism of the government, and each studiously praises Ho Chi Minh.

    ...Such protests over land could become the most serious flashpoint in Vietnam. In both the cities and the countryside, the rules are unclear as to who owns what. Some minorities in the central highlands can own and sell their land, and may even pass it on to their children. But most Vietnamese are given only leases on their land—which the government may reassess and share out again at a later date. Demonstrations over land claims and corruption, as in China, have erupted in the poorer northern provinces and elsewhere. Now they are spreading to the cities. In mid-October, farmers from the north staged a protest in central Hanoi against corruption.
    Politically, Vietnam does not have the luxury of being a huge 600 lb. gorilla on the block like China, nor the hubris of being the "dragon kingdom." It has a history of being conquered by China--even longer than the French--and therefore needs the help of the United States. It also is not in the WTO yet, and needs America's help to gain entry to the WTO and its economic benefits.

    Socially, Vietnam never underwent a "cultural revolution" like China. The Vietnam war was a war of unification, a civil war. Although many South Vietnamese escaped to the United States and Europe, many stayed in Vietnam. Also, Vietnam in general had more experience with democracy as a colony under France, and then South Vietnam under the United States, than China had before Mao. People who live in the south still remember what life was like. Many have family in Europe and the USA, I would venture to say a larger percentage of the population than in China, and they are influenced by family members sending money back as well as in thought. Even children of party members sent to the US or Europe become influenced by western thought. Then they return and enter public service in Vietnam.

    Finally, and here's the culmination of the argument, it all adds up to people's acceptance of Vietnam in its current state. Vietnam focuses on stability while China focuses on economic power. Nguyen Cong Tan, deputy prime minister, said Vietnam must
    strike a very good balance between economic growth and stability.

    ...We must pay a lot of attention to stability. We have gone through many anguishes and wars. Not every country is stable. We must focus on keeping stable. A gap between rich and poor can lead to instability.
    Sure Vietnam's not perfect, and definitely needs to address certain issues, but it is not undergoing the social insurrection that China is. Its people have jobs, the government is willing to make concessions for economic gain, they have religion (which China does not--and that helps breed freedom of thought and acceptance of differences), and although there is increasing class separation and poverty, Vietnam is slowly combatting these issues.

    Therefore, I could see change coming to Vietnam quicker than China, but I do not see riots and violence as the method. Vietnam deals with those things, but not to the extent China does. I think the new generation will enter the party, assume positions in the government, and govern according to their experiences, that include life in Vietnam as well as life in the USA. By necessity, as they work for less corruption, greater efficiency, and improving quality of life, they will adopt the traits of government that best allow seamless governing and progression. A couple weeks ago, The Economist (subscription required) wrote about this (Nov. 26th edition) mixture of privatization, good and bad, and said,
    There are problems, of course. The authorities have recently conceded that Vietnam will not join the World Trade Organisation this year, as they had hoped. Indeed, Vietnam is in the midst of trade disputes with both the United States and the European Union. It stands accused of exporting everything from catfish to bicycles at predatory prices. But Vietnamese exporters seem remarkably adaptable.

    ...Exports continue to grow at a steady clip of 20% or so a year. Seen in that light, Vietnam's many trade disputes are not so much a concern as a heartening indication of how competitive the country's exports are.

    ...Economists complain that Vietnam has plenty of tiny mom-and-pop outfits and big state-owned or foreign-invested firms, but nothing in between.

    ...[The government] recently announced that it would start selling shares in one of its four banks—but not a controlling stake, and only in small instalments spread out over five years.

    The ultimate goal seems to be a web of partially privatised companies, subject to a certain degree of competition and market discipline, akin to Singapore's government-linked companies.
    As long as Vietnam continues to make human rights and civil rights progress necessary to allow effective governing and gain entry into the WTO plus please the USA, people will not kick against the pricks. If, however, Vietnam reacts to something by clamping down on freedoms already enjoyed by the majority, I could see the process speeding up and including riots.

    Tuesday, December 13, 2005

    A new Writer

    I want to give a hearty welcome to the newest member of The Bleeding Ear--the Anonymous Cyclist. I know him/her well, and we share a love for cycling (albeit he/she's much better and more versed in it than I am). Because of that, I feel it's a perfect match--often our ears bleed as we discuss the idiocies of people in cycling or outside it.

    His/her inaugural post on sharing the road can be found right below this post (here). I will continue to post the typical things that interest me, and more cycling posts will follow -- this will be good during the Tour de France (possibly my favorite sporting event) because of his/her depth of knowledge and backing of T'Mobile (I like Discovery Channel).

    And so, without further ado, The Bleeding Ear welcomes the Anonymous Cyclist.

    Cyclists, Vehicles, and Why pieces of forged metal cost SOO much!


    What do you get when you place a one ton car driven by an underaged driver, an infinately long road, and a cyclist riding a sweet Dura-Ace 10 and sub-1 kilo carbon frame?

    CRASH!!!

    For some odd reason, I never read in the driver's handbook that cars have COMPLETE reign of the road. Why can't the cars move over? What does it take to give 3 feet to a cyclist? maybe only 2 feet! Or do you all love BLOOD of cyclists running freely in the streets? Is it because you can't take the sight of a healthy cyclist who'd rather sit on a 8 inch by 2 inch saddle instead of an armchair? Or is it the lycra? Or maybe it is the cost of buying and maintaining a bike?

    Cost. See that wonderful little picture I placed in this article. Imagine that you would have to work over 160 hours at McDonalds to pay for just those parts of a VERY good road bike. Now let's add the cost of a frame (sub-1 kilo). 256+ hours. Add the fork. 65+ hours. Why? We are only talking about carbon, aluminum, and a tad bit of titanium. Yeah yeah. I have heard the excuses. Here is a good one. The new Airbus fleet production has limited the amount of carbon to be used in the cycling industry. Meaning. We poor cyclists will have to either pay highly inflated prices or suffer with roads that need to be better maintained all the while being on guard against the underage drivers who believe the ENTIRE road from curb to curb belongs to them.


    Happy riding!

    AnonCyclist

    Saturday, December 10, 2005

    A Homosexual Pill?

    Alright, this and this have finally pushed me to post on a very sensitive topic in America today, but one I have been mulling over the last 3-4 days or so.

    Clearly, homosexuality is changing in America. Currently, best estimates show people who define themselves openly as gay or lesbian at around 8% of the populace--statice since numbers were first taken.

    However, as shown in Brokeback Mountain, homsexuality is becoming far more open in America's culture.

    Is there historical precedent?? Yes. Homsexuality has been around since historians first started writing. Ancient Greece was known for its rampant homosexuality, pedophilia, and bestiality. Young boys were expected to be lovers to the men for whom they apprenticed, and marriage ages often meant the child was closer in age to the mother than the father (often 35-40 year old men would marry 12-14 year old girls). This also explains why the oedipal complex wasn't such a big deal back then (or uncommon).

    Rome conquered Greece, and in its leaders love affair with Greek philosophy, they also adopted its Bacchinalian additude about life, including orgies and open homosexuality.

    With the conservative Christian backlash during the darkages, homosexuality became known as "the Greek plague." It never went away, but was definitely stifled socially. Today, as western society again adopts the Bacchinalian attitude of ancient Rome and Greece, our love for life's pleasures has again led to a social acceptance of homosexuality.

    This is not just a western thing. I'm currently watching a pretty good anime called Samurai Champloo (also see here). It's not a history, but it is set in the Edo period of Japan (before the Meiji Revolution). This reminded me of my asian history classes, where the Edo time was also characterized by rampant sexuality. Homosexuality in Japan during the Edo period was regarded as the highest form of love. A recent movie I saw (and did not like) on this issue is Taboo (also see here). Of course, the Japanese culture was always sexual before that, including but not limited to, polygamy, widespread acceptance of mistresses on top of plural wives, etc. Japanese culture went through an anti-homosexual backlash of its own right after the Meiji Revolution.

    So what does this huge tangent prove? Nothing, really. Just what we all know. Homosexuality is not new, nor is social acceptance of it.

    But what is new is science--biochemistry, microbiology, psychiatry, neurology. That is a field I am immersed in every day. At work we frequently discuss the biochemistry of the myriad of mental illnesses diagnosed today. I have intimate experience with manic depression. Coworkers have had family members with various other mental issues.

    Mental problems stem often from a mixture of nature/nurture. What I mean is that life experiences can make people depressed, as can chemical imbalances. Often the two combine in certain ways to exacerbate the issue. For some people it is more chemcial than experience, and for others it is more experience and less chemical.

    Currently, scientists are addressing this issue in alcoholism.
    Serotonergic and anticonvulsant agents promise to play more of a role in the treatment of alcohol dependence. Although not approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration for this indication, the anticonvulsant topiramate and several serotonergic agents (e.g., fluoxetine, ondansetron) have been shown in recent studies to increase abstinence rates and decrease drinking.
    From ADD/ADHD to manic depression and shizoparanoism, western medicine is using pills to correct chemical imbalances in people and treat these diseases. Now western medicine has taken the step towards treating behavior. Alcoholism has symptomology of a mental disorder, but it also stems from behavior (versus manic depression, which you just have, and affects how you react to situations). Someone may be biochemcially predisposed to alcoholism, but if he/she never drinks, he/she will not be an alcoholic. Alcoholism is seen as socially destructive and society views the action negatively. A drug working on serotonin or another receptor that quenches the desire to drink, and hence stops alcoholism, helps the mental issue, but also attacks a social ill.

    So where does it stop? Should it stop? If homosexuality has a biochemical cause in addition to a "nurture" aspect, then it too could be curbed or changed by pills that target certain biochemical pathways. Not only homosexuals--anyone with a "deviant" sexual prediliction could be "fixed" with a pill--rapists, pedophiles, necrophiles, or people deemed to have an overactive sexual appetite. All it would take is identifying what hormone paths are turned on, and modify them.

    But what about limits? Who defines what is "deviant" and what is not? Obviously, christian religious conservatives believe homosexuality is morally wrong, but I doubt anybody would put it on a footing with alcoholism. Society does not see it as a social ill in that sense. Who are we to determine that homosexuality is deviant and should be curbed (with a pill)? But then, if we can't, why are we justified in doing it for other sexual behaviors such as pedophilia?

    Obviously the current limit is harm it causes another. Homosexuality harms nobody because consenting adults participate. Rape, pedophilia, etc all harm others against their will.

    Should a pill be pursued? Many people are very happy with their homosexuality, and would not want a pill. Perhaps even offended by the notion. But what of others, who have strong religious beliefs in opposition to homosexuality? Would such a pill be a God-send--allowing he or she to live a life in concordance with their personal faith? And then what of the opposite? If a pill curbing homosexual tendencies could be manufactured, could it's opposite also be manufactured? Would it be the right of two homosexual parents to give their adopted children such a pill to make them homosexual as well? Or what of heterosexual parents who notice homosexual tendencies in their children under 18? Do they have the right to give a pill to their children and curb their homosexuality before he or she has the ability to determine for his or herself whether they want to be homosexual or not??

    This issue has been bouncing around my head for days now. I believe that a pill curbing sexual appetites of all variations is definitely feasable, if society wants to make it. And then, all of these ethical dilemmas will become paramount. I definitely have no answers for these questions, but I would like to discuss this with others. What do you think?

    Blogs on the Chinese Riots

    I haven't been successful in finding blogs in China discussing the riots. It's entirely probable that the government is suppressing what little blogs are allowed.

    I have found various different reactions to it. I agree with some, and violently disagree with others. You can decide for yourself.

    Intelligence Summit is a news report.

    Right Wing Dad is just that, a right wing from NY reaction.

    Culture of Life Breaking News is a very liberal reaction from NY.

    Gateway Pundit is doing the usual good job at chronicalling the action, with pics.

    I will post more as I find it.

    Friday, December 09, 2005

    Chinese Killings

    I stayed with a couple in Boston a month back when I went out there to interview. He felt we might have an escalation with China and eventual war. I disagreed for many reasons, mostly political, but one I didn't mention at the time was economic--China will become democratic.

    This is proof. People, even those used to living in a confucian-dominated society of order, will eventually clammer for rights, representation, and decency. The communist party in China has given none of these to its citizens, but now the citizens are becoming wealthier, and have greater access to outside knowledge. There will be a revolution. It's only a matter of time. CNN reports,
    The number of protests in China's vast, poverty-stricken countryside has risen in recent months as anger comes to a head over land seizures, corruption and a yawning wealth gap that experts say threatens social stability. The government says about 70,000 such conflicts occurred last year, although many more are believed to have gone unreported.

    The clashes also have become increasingly violent, with injuries sustained on both sides and huge amounts of damage done to property as protesters vent their frustration in face of indifferent or bullying authorities.


    Today police killed ten demonstrators, wounded 20 more, and many others are "missing" after villagers from a small southern town gathered to protest their low renumeration for land taken to build a wind power plant.

    Thousands of people gathered Tuesday in Dongzhou, in southern Guangdong province, to protest the amount of money offered by the government as compensation for land taken to construct a wind power plant.
    But here's what really got me as typical China and the reason the government won't last forever:
    State media have not mentioned the violence, and both provincial and local governments have repeatedly refused to comment. This is typical in China, where the ruling Communist Party controls the media and lower-level authorities are leery of releasing information without permission from the central government.
    Just like they did with the benzene spill a little while back. The government is inept. It tries to cover up its mistakes and looks stupider. And people in America want to move to socialization like socialized medicine....

    Thursday, December 08, 2005

    Man Shot by Air Marshall

    This is a sad story for all involved. I wouldn't wish it on the man, wife, or the air marshall.

    But there's nothing you can do. We have air marshalls on planes for bomb situations. Regardless of the reason why, if someone says they have a bomb, you must take them seriously. How horrible would you feel if you shot the suspect's leg, or fired a warning shot, just to be sure, and then he/she detonated a real bomb and killed numerous people? An air marshall just can't take those chances.

    If anything it reinforces the unseen verity of air marshalls protecting us on highly trafficked flights. It also shows the very real problems associated with mental disorders. An old girlfriend of mine was bipolar went through a period of experimentation with different medications. It was hard. She was a bright, loving, beautiful girl, but she would be happy and jittery for 36 hours and then depressed for the next 36 sometimes. When she was up, she was the most amazing woman I ever met--able to accomplish anything--a true mover and shaker. But when she was down, I really had to work with her to get her out of bed in the morning.

    And so all this combined in a truly tragic situation. So many "if's." If only they had brought his medication...if only he had followed orders...who knows.

    Wednesday, December 07, 2005

    I'm Dreaming of a White Christmas

    Christmas is really here, and these pictures don't even do it justice. It snowed all day yesterday, and these pics are from before that. Tonight I'm going to help my wife make her first snowman.

    100_1442South Provo.

    100_1439BYU Campus.

    100_1438From my bedroom window.

    Tuesday, December 06, 2005

    You Must Watch This

    This is my absolute favorite music video of all time. I've loved it ever since my brother sent me the link to it a couple years back. I found this link to it so I could show it to a coworker. Even if you are not a music video type, you will be moved by this one. Watch. Enjoy. Tell me what you think.

    Bush vs. Clinton

    Often I hear people complain about President Bush and compare him to President Clinton in the same breath. I summarize the two presidents like this:

    President Bush is the mayor of a town. He sees a fire in the woods near the town, and in order to protect the town from the fire, he decides to dig a trench between the forest and the town. However, he uses a bulldozer to do this, and knocks down half the forest to protect the town.

    President Clinton is the mayor of a town. He sees a fire in the woods near the town, and in order to protect the town from the fire, he orders people to build wells and spins it as economic growth. The wells provide water to put out the fire when it reaches the town, however, the forest is lost and some houses on the fringe while townspeople dig the wells and fight the fire.

    People of both sides have their issues. Does Bush really need to use a bulldozer and destroy all that forest?? Did Clinton really need to build a well instead of using the water already available in a nearby stream or previous wells??

    Critics today say Bush has used too much power in Iraq preempting terrorism, and Clinton didn't do enough when there was genocide in Rwanda. No, no whole countries will be annihilated like the forest, my point is to argue that both presidents end up with the same amount of damage, only Bush causes part of it and Clinton allows others to cause all of it.

    I don't think either way is good. I feel that a pit should be dug, but a small, manageable one. Not one with a bulldozer, and not a well.

    Please, opine.

    Happy Day!!

    Two reasons!

    1. Wife finally finished the interview and should get the green card in the mail! (sans some stupid glitches known to inefficient governments...)

    2. I got accepted to the Medical College of Wisconsin!

    Friday, December 02, 2005

    Teen kills cyclist

    I hope he gets the full year in jail.

    China Abuses prisoners?

    I'm glad what seems to be common knowledge is finally corroborated by the United Nations. Now, what will be done about it??

    Call me a cynic, but the USA has known for 50 years that possibly the grossest of human rights violations (at least in scale) have been occuring in China. 9 out of 10 political activists in jail around the world are in jail in China. I don't think much is going to come from this.

    Thursday, December 01, 2005

    Goals Gone Wild

    You have to read this story. I love it. I just wish there was more info, or that I could get a hold of the paper.

    I think people need to lay off. Obviously, for better or worse, "Girls Gone Wild" videos have become entrenched in American culture (I would say worse, but I don't run this country). It is a direct result of the women's liberation movement that women's free sexuality has become objectified and "playboy bunnified." It's no longer taboo. It's no longer wrong for men and womento look at and pose in pornographic magazines.

    So, that being said, I think this shot and article is a great satire of current American society. The bras are sponsored by Big Johnson, a famous in the south brand with obvious sexual connotations, and a stab directly at the phenom softcore voyeur porn that has become entrenched in American college culture today.

    Stop complaining about this picture, and, if you don't like it, fight against the movies that spawn such social commentary. Or even better, the patrons that buy it and the girls that star in it. That's where the problem lies.

    Wednesday, November 30, 2005

    Phony Marriages

    I read this at Fox, but cannot seem to find anything about in in Viet newspapers, specifically the Viet Bao and the Nguoi Viet. Fox reports that
    Federal authorities arrested 11 people in connection with a sophisticated marriage fraud scheme that targeted Asians seeking U.S. citizenship.

    ...The arrests took place Tuesday in Los Angeles and Orange counties and the Bay Area, according to officials who described the operation as one of the biggest of its kind in the country.

    Chinese and Vietnamese nationals were charged up to $60,000 to marry American citizens to obtain green cards, authorities said. Couples were provided with fake wedding photographs, joint tax returns and even love letters.
    This is incredibly common. I can't number the amount of websites I've ran across on the internet that hawk arranged marriages, nor the number of people I know in Orange County who are in them.

    I have always been opposed. This is not specifically a white American thing, either. Many who do this are native Viet men who want the cash or in a slight variation, want a young Vietnamese wife.

    One woman I knew who came over on an arranged marriage was stuck without any legal standing when her husband left her. In order to get a green card, you must have proof that you have been married for two years. I know this intimately, because my wife was born in Vietnam, and we had to go through the process when we got married. However, in the case of my acquaintance, she got pregnant. In many arrainged marriages, obviously, love and even physical attraction are non-existent. The husband figured that since she was his wife, he had right to have sex with her whenever he wanted, even though she didn't love him at all (and he didn't love her) and she protested. Everything was fine in his eyes until she got pregnant, and then he threw her out on the street and refused to deal with her. Although technically still married on paper, she had no copy of the document, and her temporary green card expired, leaving her without the ability to get a job or healthcare.

    Also, in the other type of marriage, I knew a woman, Van, who was forced by her family to marry a Viet kieu 20 years older than her. He was happy to get a young, beautiful wife, but she had no feelings of love for him. He also would not let her get a job or learn English, because he wanted to make sure she stayed dependent (and therefore faithful) on him.

    In either situation, the big problem is the use of the woman. Her decision, her feelings, are lost for a couple bucks. Children born to women in either situation grow up in often disfunctional households. Now, this is not to discount that someone can (and often does) meet another person through a marriage company who they truly fall in love with and have a great life together. Just like online dating services, "mail-order bride" services can be ok. However, in many cases, they are scams like the one reported, or at least result in almost in-house slavery to the woman who entered the marriage not of her own free will and has no skill to give her any recourse in her new country.

    I hope the government continues to crack down on these scams. Also, any other links to more info on this article in other (particularly Vietnamese) newspapers would be helpful. I'm curious as to why they haven't reported it yet.

    Tuesday, November 29, 2005

    Rising Healthcare Costs

    Last month’s issue of Forbes highlights a growing problem in medicine—excessive compensation. What should we do, if anything, to people profiting generously from a $2 trillion dollar healthcare system with costs spiraling out of hand? For example, one New York lawyer works about 40 cases of birthing malpractice a year. He charges routinely that mistakes made during the birth caused a baby’s situation, such as cerebral palsy. Usually, insurance companies settle out of court. In one case mentioned in the article, he made over $10 million for the baby’s parents, took $1.4 million for himself, and then asked the judge to up his cut to $2.2 million citing long hours and complexity of the case—even though both arguments are expressedly forbidden as ways to improve payment in New York’s sliding scale method.

    Today more than a quarter of all Americans are uninsured. I am one of them. My employer offers no coverage, even though I work 40 hours a week. My wife, still a student, gets minimal coverage. This topic has engendered discussion from the white house to my interviews at medical school, as doctors and politicians alike try to grasp the gravity of the situation and direction reform must take. What should we do? A couple weeks ago, in Massachusetts, the House of Representatives passed a version of a bill put forward by Gov. Mitt Romney. It still needs approval by the State Senate before it becomes law. This bill would require employers to provide minimal coverage for workers.

    But on the flip side, surveys show that at least 70,000-90,000 people in Massachusetts make more than three times the poverty level and do not have coverage. These individuals obviously choose not to, because monetarily it is well within their ability. The proposed bill would also require people above the poverty line to have some form of medical coverage. Problem solved, right? Wrong.

    The “taxachusetts” bill (as a Bostonian called his state when I was talking to him on the subway), provides a viable way for the government to help curb the rising number of uninsured. I think it might be the best plan I’ve heard of so far, but that doesn’t make it the right way of dealing with the problem.

    I work with Buruli ulcer. It is a disease endemic in West Africa and Northern Australia. The bacteria enter through a cut in the skin, then causes a bump to form. Eventually that bump opens into a painless skin lesion (ulcer) that gradually gets bigger until it may cover up to 70% of the body. Eventually, the immune system gets a hold of this bug, and the lesions scar over; often resulting in contracture deformities.

    If a doctor put a bandaid on the bump or small lesion then nothing would happen. It might protect the lesion from secondary infections, but not stop its growth or eventual scarring. The only way to treat the disease (since antibiotics do not work) is to cut out the bump before a lesion is formed and stitch up the skin, or cut away the lesion and use skin grafts to fill it back.

    I have a feeling America’s heathcare system is a large nodule about to ulcerate. Public policy initiatives, although great bandaids, are not surgical excisions and will not stop the progression of the ulcer. The heart of the healthcare matter, is two issues. 1) litigation causes huge costs to hospitals and doctors that are passed down to consumers, and 2) as medicine gets more advanced costs rise to pay for the increasingly complex procedures and research.

    If America’s lawmakers and policy wizards can strike to the heart of these two issues, the cost of managed healthcare will decrease, and more people will be able to afford health insurance.

    Attacking these two issues also allows us to bypass the horrid idea of standardizing healthcare like Canada and Great Britain. My coworker Mike’s sister lives in Britain, and when she needed an MRI, she had to wait months because of the waiting list. In medicine, hours and days can mean the difference between life and death, let alone months. Socialized medicine brings medicine down to the lowest level of service possible, because it does not allow for prompt and efficient care, nor give incentives to healthcare workers to enter medicine and succeed. With socialized medicine comes standardized salaries, and the decreased pay will dissuade more prospective doctors from joining the profession. Hence, a lower caliber doctor will practice, and he or she will have less incentive to work their hardest to save a patient because the return on such sacrifice is less, and often futile when a patient must wait long periods for critical tests or treatments.

    So how do we deal with the problems? First, we need better tort reform. My grandfather died due to malpractice. I know it happens, acutely. However, many lawsuits, like Mr. Moore’s cerebral palsy lawsuit, are frivolous. An overabundance of information shows that nothing in the birthing process can cause cerebral palsy, but insurance companies settle out of court because it’s less costly then waging legal war, and the cost is passed on to you and me. All states should pass laws limiting damages juries can award, as well as payment lawyers can make from a verdict. Also, physicians need to create a contractual relationship with the patient that says something to this effect:

    “You, the patient, contract with me, the physician, to provide your healthcare. By signing this contract you acknowledge that there are many physicians and you have chosen me to direct your care of your own free will and knowledge. You consent to all treatments I deem necessary except those that are expressedly forbidden by your faith or creed, and if you refuse tests and procedures forbidden by your faith or creed, you take full legal, ethical, and physical responsibility for the outcome of the whole course of treatment. Also, you acknowledge that human error is part of the fallible nature of man and if you feel that I did not perform to the best of my ability and this caused undue harm to the outcome of the course of treatment, you agree to settle such grievance outside of court via arbitration.”

    Obviously this language is just my own words, but the gist can be put into binding legal jargon. Such a disclaimer would free the doctor to pursue the course of treatment he or she feels is best for the patient and limit liability for errors.

    In addition, government subsidies for increased competition among medical technology companies will drive down costs of tests. Also, physicians need to set up advisory boards that deal with test efficacy. The Anesthesiology society of America did so in the late 1990s and malpractice insurance has only risen along with inflation since then. Test efficacy boards will determine if tests are being order too much, instruct doctors, and find machines that do not fail, or techniques that work better, to lower malpractice incidence and rates.

    Ultimately, this requires a concerted effort by both the government and physicians in tackling these two issues. Doing so will defeat the ulcer at its source, before it festers.

    Sunday, November 27, 2005

    Avian Flu Update 2

    I am constantly impressed with Vietnam's public health response to disease. Vietnam is what the state department calls a "second tier country." Its economy and standard of living is improving, but it has lots of problems--corruption and inefficiency in the government, lack of unified health infrastructure between urban and rural areas, and liquid capital to build transportation infrastructure and buy necessary equipment to fight disease.

    Dealing with all that, Vietnam's Ministry of Health did an amazing job fighting SARS in 2003. They put aside the typical asian "don't want to lose face" attitude and were very open and cooperative with the WHO. It admitted it had problems that prevented Vietnam from effectively dealing with SARS. Its response led to rapid detection, quarantine, and treatment of the disease. Most importantly, it used SARS to learn and prepare for another eventual disease outbreak.

    So, this week Vietnam held a mock bird flu exercise. In it, the faked a human-to-human bird flu in Hanoi, quarantined off that part of the city, set up make-shift triage centers, disinfected buildings and cycles--all with 900 health professionals and soldiers. Obiously, translating a mock drill in one part of Hanoi into reality throughout the country will be difficult, but Vietnam is working on it.

    The bird flu is scary. 68 people have died in Vietnam so far, and the mortality rate is over 50%. That could mean nothing more than a little stronger flu if it went pandemic or a massive killer. It's hard to translate the mortality rate because many do not seek treatment until very sick and come from the rural areas where medical infrastructure is weak or non-existent. What we can know, is that Vietnam is doing amazingly well in making sure it is ready for any eventuality.

    In contrast, China has again shown ineptitude and extreme hubris with its handling of the benzene slick. Today, China returned running water to the city of Harbin, but it still cannot be drunk. Chinese politicians fiddled while Rome burned, and they should be publicly flogger for it. Regardless of political ideology, communist, republic, democractic, no government is allowed to coverup the needless deaths of citizens. Chinese leaders told nobody about the slick until the benzene slick was in Harbin and now five people are dead. Who knows how many more are sick. The city could have been far more prepared if people had known to stock up on water beforehand, instead of fearing the rumors. More importantly, other countries could have helped Chinese authorities deal with the slick before it hit Harbin, possibly avoiding danger all together. Now it is moving towards Russia, and if I was Pres. Putin, I'd be pretty pissed at Hu Jintao for not cleaning up the mess, and demand China pays for its cleanup and any problems it causes Russia.

    Cheers to Vietnam for effective health planning, and many large jeers to China for its bumbling.

    Friday, November 25, 2005

    Avian Flu Update

    It looks like China's finally caught the avian flu bug. Tuesday, China reported it's second death in a few days, a 35-year old woman from the Anhui province. China has over 15 billion birds...

    Vietnam is also undergoing another outbreak in chickens. The latest fatality is a 15 year old boy from Hai Phong. The government has told tour agencies not to take foreigners by places with birds because it cannot handle deaths of foreigners.

    For more information, check this link, but you will need a subscription to the wall street journal.

    Thursday, November 24, 2005

    Vietnam Sex Tourism

    Alright, so Bangkok is bad, not just for the euphemisms, but because of what we ALL know goes on there. Vietnam, for its part, has done, I think, a remarkable job fighting this. However, nothing is perfect, and it still goes on far too often in the motherland. Take Gary Glitter for example. I first heard this from The Rice Bowl and nearly puked. The man has been previously convicted of 54 counts of posessing child pornography, and he's spent time in Cambodia, now Vietnam, and was trying to get to Thailand.

    Adults can be adults, and if someone from outside Vietnam was attracted to a Vietnamese woman, my response would be "of course"! I think they are very attractive, hence I married my wife. But in Vietnam, where the age of consent is already low at 16, do you really have to go for 8, 10, and 12 year olds. Gosh, Vietnam has enough problems as it struggles to overcome the hyperinflation of the 1980s, the vestiges of the Vietnam war (for arguably 50 years before 1975), and the cultural revolution it is undergoing due to MTV. Do you have to throw in sexual predators too? Maybe it's my hatred of pedophiles, or the softspot in my heart for Vietnam, but it sickens me.

    When I was in Vietnam last year, I remember distinctly walking down a street in Hanoi and having two young women on a motorbike ride up next to me (at about 10:00pm) and ask if I wanted "boom boom." What a perfect english euphemism for sex. It's descriptive but leaves you with only the physical inference of sex, not any of the emotional or psychological bonds that develop from a healthy relationship.

    When I met my friends, Phuong and Hai, in Sapa later on, they told me of visiting a massage parlor on the road from Hanoi to Sapa. In it, Phuong talked to his massuse who spoke southern. He was shocked. You don't find many in the North. "Why are you up here"? he asked. She proceeded to tell him that she came from a rural area in the south and her parents sent her and her sister up north to work in massage parlors and make money. They encouraged, even demanded, that she and her sister sleep with patrons to make more money. She confided in Phuong that she and her sister continually angered their parents by not doing that, and they were secretly saving money to buy a house and go to college. When that day happened, they could finally be rid of their parents' evil demands.

    At The Rice Bowl, Pieman makes good comments about the prevalence of the underage sex trade to native Viets. It is not just a westerner thing. Vietnam has outlawed Vietnamese nationals going into hotels with westerners of the opposite sex to try and curb this, and two years ago tried to shut down all karaoke bars (although the nation almost revolted and it was stopped). Although the Vietnamese government is doing good things in its fight against child prostitution, it will fight a losing battle until it tackles the economic disparity between Ho Chi Minh City and the rest of Vietnam that causes parents to urge their children to sell their bodies, and young girls to move to the city and whore themselves.

    America and other countries have extra-territorial laws to prosecute predators oversees, but it isn't enough. Look up Vietnam's status on fighting this here. Here's a link for how you may help.

    Texas High School Football

    Some of you might have seen Friday Night Lights. If so, you may understand, a little, what high school football is in Texas. Football is life. If you aren't playing football, it must be baseball season. If you're not playing either, you may be stuck on a basketball court, but only because you can't get a place big enough for football or baseball. And if you aren't doing any of that, you just ain't living.

    Knowing this, I was not surprised to see four Texas high schools in the top 25 HS football teams in the nation according to Sports Illustrated. I was not surprised to see Texas have 4 teams in the top 25, more than any other state. Carroll HS, from Southlake, TX took #1, and deserves recognition, but Westfield (Spring, TX--right outside Houston and one I've seen play) took 8th, Lufkin took 18th, and Abilene took 21st.

    So, on such a great football holiday like Thanksgiving, props to Texas High School Football!